How to Pick a Breast Pump

April 23, 2025

Choosing a breast pump can feel overwhelming at first—especially with so many breast pump types, brands, and features on the market. Whether you’re a first-time mother preparing for breastfeeding or a seasoned parent looking to upgrade your lactation machine, understanding the different kinds of breast pumps (from hospital-grade to wearable) can make all the difference in ensuring a smooth and efficient experience.

In this comprehensive “breast pump guide,” we’ll explore what to look for in a breast pump, the types of breast pumps available, which breast pump is right for you, and how to use a breast pump effectively once you’ve made your choice. We’ll also discuss key questions to ask yourself, provide a “breast pump comparison” table for various recommended pumps (including suction settings and cycle speed), and share tips gathered from lactation experts and trusted resources.

By the end of this article, you’ll have a detailed roadmap to help you in choosing a breast pump that fits your lifestyle, supports your breastfeeding goals, and keeps both you and your baby happy.

SECTION 1: Why Use a Breast Pump?

SECTION 2: How Do Breast Pumps Work?

2.1 The Two Main Modes of Electric Pumps

Side Note: The Letdown Reflex

SECTION 3: Types of Breast Pumps (Overview)

1. Primary Breast Pumps

SECTION 4. Primary Pumps

4.1 Primary Pumps

Spectra S1 & Spectra S2

4.2 Portable Pumps That Are Sometimes Considered Primary

BabyBuddha 2.0

Pumpables Genie Advanced

Side Note: How to Go Hands-Free with Primary Breast Pumps

SECTION 5. Secondary Pumps

5.1 Portable Pumps

5.1.1 Portable Pumps with Traditional Flanges & Bottles

Idaho Jones Twain

Idaho Jones Moxi

Ardo Alyssa

5.1.2 Portable Pumps with Wearable Collection Cups

5.3 A Third Must-Have: The Medela Manual Pump

Medela Harmony Manual Pump

SECTION 6: Key Questions to Consider

SECTION 7: Frequently Asked Questions

SECTION 8: Conclusion

References

SECTION 1: Why Use a Breast Pump?

A breast pump can be a game-changer for many breastfeeding parents, whether you need occasional relief from engorgement or plan to pump multiple times a day. Here are just a few reasons why you might want a breast pump:

Flexibility and Convenience

Pumping allows you to collect and store milk so someone else can feed your baby while you work, run errands, or just take a break.

Going Back to Paid Work

If you are returning to paid work, pumping can allow you to continue your breastfeeding journey well past your maternity leave.

Maintaining or Increasing Milk Supply

Regular pumping stimulates milk production. This is key if you’re dealing with low supply or want to build a freezer stash.

Helping Babies with Special Circumstances

Babies who have difficulty latching, are premature, or have certain medical issues can still benefit from breast milk via bottle-feeding with pumped milk.

Relieving Engorgement and Clogged Ducts

A breast pump can help clear out milk and alleviate discomfort when you’re too full or dealing with a blockage.

Whether you want to know how breast pumps work, what to look for in a breast pump, or which breast pump is best, having the right information helps you pick a device that meets your personal needs.

SECTION 2: How Do Breast Pumps Work?

When people ask, “How does a breast pump work?” the basic mechanism is simple: a motor (or manual lever) creates suction, drawing the nipple into a flange and extracting milk. Then the suction releases, and the cycle repeats—mimicking the natural suckling pattern of a baby.

Different breast pumps have different:

Vacuum Range: suction strength
Cycle Speeds: how many times per minute the pump sucks and releases

These affect their pumping efficiency and ability to be customized to users’ needs.

2.1 The Two Main Modes of Electric Pumps

Stimulation (Letdown) Mode:
This is a faster, lighter suction designed to spark the letdown reflex—a hormonal response (driven by oxytocin) causing milk ducts to contract, pushing milk toward the nipple. So high cycle speed and low vacuum.
Expression Mode:
Once letdown is achieved and milk is flowing, the pump often slows the cycle speed but increases the suction strength, similar to a baby’s deeper, more deliberate sucking.

Side Note: The Letdown Reflex

The letdown reflex (also called the milk ejection reflex) is when your body releases milk from the alveoli (milk-making cells) into the ducts. Some people feel a tingling sensation, some feel a warmth or fullness, and some feel very little physically but see the milk flow. Stress and discomfort can hinder letdown, so proper flange fit and a calm environment can make a big difference.

SECTION 3: Types of Breast Pumps (Overview)

Breast pumps generally fall into three categories:

Primary Breast Pumps

A primary breast pump is designed for frequent, daily use and helps you reliably pump breast milk several times each day. It’s specifically made to support your milk supply, whether you’re exclusively pumping, trying to boost milk production, or maintaining your supply over time.

Key features of a primary breast pump include:

Durable Motor: Built to handle multiple pumping sessions daily without losing power.
Reliable Performance: Proven to maintain or increase milk production effectively.
Customizable Settings: Allows you to adjust suction strength and speed to match your comfort and needs.

2. Secondary Pumps

A secondary breast pump is lighter, smaller, and designed primarily for convenience, portability, or discreet pumping. However, they may not fully empty the breasts, which could sometimes lead to milk supply issues if used frequently.

Secondary pumps fall into two main categories:

2.1 Portable Pumps

Portable pumps are those that have a small motor and a rechargeable battery, making them easier to carry around. They still have tubing attached to the traditional flange + bottle set up or to collection cups.

2.2 Wearable Pumps

Wearable pumps are breast pumps designed to fit entirely within your bra, combining the motor, flange, and collection container into a single unit, eliminating the need for tubing or a separate hands-free bra.

Bonus: Manual Pumps

A manual breast pump is a handheld, non-electric pump used to express breast milk. It works by manually pressing down a lever or handle, creating suction that draws milk out of the breast. It’s compact, portable, quiet, and ideal for occasional or on-the-go pumping sessions.

SECTION 4. Primary Pumps

Here, we provide an initial review of the pumps that are most recommended by lactation consultants to be used as primary pumps. With this information, you can hopefully form an initial opinion and make a shortlist of the pumps that will work best for you.

4.1 Primary Pumps

These are dependable and robust pumps for daily or exclusive pumping. You can get most of them through your insurance.

Spectra S1 & Spectra S2

Effect on Supply: Excellent for maintaining or increasing milk supply; highly recommended for first-time or low-supply moms.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Offers independently adjustable vacuum and cycle speed settings

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 54
Max vacuum (mmHg): 270

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast: No, single motor only.
Rechargeable: S1 has a rechargeable battery; S2 is plug-in only.
Size: Portable enough but quite large and bulky
Other: Suction pattern includes vibration. While most moms like this, some don’t.

Sources:

Spectra Synergy Gold

Effect on Supply: Powerful, highly effective pump for maintaining or increasing supply; great for complex pumping scenarios.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Yes, independently adjustable vacuum and cycle speed for each breast.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 54
Max vacuum (mmHg): 270

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, offers independent control per side.
Rechargeable: No, must be plugged into an outlet.
Size: Larger, heavier, less portable.

Sources:

Unimom Opera

Effect on Supply: Very effective; known for fast emptying and excellent performance, beneficial for difficult letdowns.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Yes, offers independent vacuum control and multiple pumping modes, including alternate suction between breasts; however, somewhat complicated to adjust.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 42
Max vacuum (mmHg): 280

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, independently adjustable motors for each breast.
Rechargeable: Yes, rechargeable battery built-in.
Size: Compact and easily portable despite its powerful motor.
Other: Despite its high price, parts feel lower quality and less durable; users may prefer replacing parts with Spectra-compatible components.

Sources:

Medela Symphony

Effect on Supply: Highly effective for initiating and maintaining milk supply; widely used in hospitals and NICUs, especially beneficial for vulnerable milk supply situations or early postpartum.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: No, preset vacuum and cycle speed combinations.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 78 (in the maintain program)
Max vacuum (mmHg): 250

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor; no independent breast control.
Rechargeable: No, requires plugging into an outlet.
Size: Large, heavy, and bulky; primarily intended as a stationary, hospital-grade pump.
Ease of Use: Simple operation with limited settings; however, parts are somewhat outdated and require frequent replacement.
Other: Widely trusted hospital-grade pump; however, expensive and typically rented rather than purchased due to high cost (~$2,000 new). Difficult to transition from this pump to others due to its unique suction pattern.

Sources:

Limerick

Effect on Supply: Highly effective at maintaining and supporting milk supply, particularly suitable for long-term use, delicate breast tissue, and complex situations like oral dysfunction or tongue-tie.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Extremely customizable, with thousands of unique combinations. Highest cycle speed range available on the market.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 78 (in the maintain program)
Max vacuum (mmHg): 250

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor; settings cannot be independently adjusted per breast.
Rechargeable: Not internally rechargeable, but easily used with an external battery pack for portability.
Size: Compact and portable; lightweight, easy to carry or wear in a fanny pack, suitable for mobile pumping.
Ease of Use: Simple to operate once settings are established; incredibly easy to clean and maintain due to minimal parts and durable construction.
Other: Uses unique constant suction technology with vibration rather than traditional pull-and-release, providing unmatched comfort. Silicone flange. FDA-approved multi-user pump, safe for multiple users. High initial cost ($500-$800), but very durable and cost-effective over long-term use.

Sources:

Ameda Platinum

Effect on Supply: Highly effective at initiating, increasing, or maintaining milk supply; particularly recommended for moms needing reliable and consistent milk removal.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Yes, fully customizable vacuum strength and cycle speeds , allowing tailored settings for maximum comfort and efficiency.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 80
Max vacuum (mmHg): 250

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor; settings apply equally to both breasts without independent control.
Rechargeable: No, requires plugging into an electrical outlet.
Size: Large and heavy (approx. 9.7 lbs), designed for stationary use rather than portability. Old-timey look.
Ease of Use: Simple, intuitive user interface.
Other: Widely trusted hospital-grade pump; however, expensive and typically rented rather than purchased due to high cost. More widely used in clinic settings.

Sources:

4.2 Portable Pumps That Are Sometimes Considered Primary

These smaller, lighter pumps can achieve suction and cycle speeds comparable to the larger units, even though they don’t have as many customization options. They are viable as a “primary” choice if your supply is robust and you respond well to the slightly limited range of settings they offer.

BabyBuddha 2.0

Effect on Supply: Very effective, particularly praised for its powerful suction that can efficiently initiate multiple letdowns, potentially shortening pumping sessions.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Offers customizable vacuum levels and cycle speeds; known for its distinct, long & sustained suction in stimulation mode.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 51
Max vacuum (mmHg): 320

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor; settings apply equally to both breasts.
Rechargeable: Yes, includes a built-in rechargeable battery, allowing maximum portability.
Size: Very compact, one of the smallest portable pumps available; highly convenient for on-the-go pumping.
Ease of Use: Generally user-friendly but requires initial experimentation to find ideal settings due to its unique suction pattern. Widely hackable and adaptable to various flange setups.
Other: Known for its long, sustained suction pattern during stimulation, which some moms love, but others may find too strong without modification. High suction can quickly wear out certain pump parts, necessitating more frequent replacements. Popular among those who need portability combined with powerful suction strength.

Souces:

Pumpables Genie Advanced

Effect on Supply: Effective at maintaining milk supply for most moms; closely matches the performance of the Spectra S1/S2, making it reliable for consistent milk removal on-the-go.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Offers four modes—one stimulation and three expression modes—each pairing suction and cycle speed together. So it has a bit of setting adjustment for vacuum and cycle speed combination. However, it lacks independent control of vacuum and cycle speed compared to full-sized pumps.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 70
Max vacuum (mmHg): 330

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor; settings are shared equally between both breasts.
Rechargeable: Yes, built-in rechargeable battery, but the pump remains fully operational even if the battery eventually fails (can run from an external battery).
Size: Compact, lightweight, and highly portable, designed for easy mobility, includes a belt clip for convenient carrying.
Ease of Use: User-friendly and straightforward with minimal buttons; the silicone "Liquid Shields" flanges are exceptionally comfortable, though may take initial practice to fit securely into certain pumping bras.
Other: Known for its gentle but effective suction, thanks to the uniquely designed soft silicone flanges (Liquid Shields), providing a massaging sensation that mimics a baby's mouth. High-quality build with excellent customer service and warranty (2 years). Not suitable for moms sensitive to vibration or those needing very high suction combined with higher cycle speeds. A popular portable alternative to larger Spectra pumps.

Sources:

Side Note: How to Go Hands-Free with Primary Breast Pumps

You don’t need to buy a wearable pump just to pump hands-free. Even larger, hospital-grade or full-size primary pumps like the Spectra S1/S2, Medela Symphony, or Unimom Opera can be used hands-free with the right accessories.

Here’s how:

Use Collection Cups: Instead of flanges and bottles hanging outside your bra, swap them for discreet in-bra collection cups like the Idaho Jones Pump-a-Collect. These cups connect to your primary pump via tubing but stay tucked inside your bra, keeping everything secure and low-profile.
Add a Carrying Solution: To be fully mobile, pair your pump and collection cups with a Pump-a-Porter or Pump-a-Porter Mini. These bags hold your pump, so you can move around (yes, even walk!) while pumping—at home, at work, or on the go.

This setup turns even the bulkiest hospital-grade pumps into a flexible, hands-free solution—without compromising on performance.

SECTION 5. Secondary Pumps

Secondary pumps tend to be lighter, smaller, or wearable. They excel in situations where you:

Already have a reliable primary pump at home or the office.
Need extra convenience for short or mobile sessions.
Want a discreet hands-free method without hooking up tubes.

There are many secondary pumps available, so we can't cover them all here. Instead, we've included the most popular ones and those most frequently recommended by lactation consultants.

5.1 Portable Pumps

5.1.1 Portable Pumps with Traditional Flanges & Bottles

Idaho Jones Twain

Effect on Supply: Effectively maintains supply, comparable performance to other higher-quality portable pumps; especially useful due to dual-motor control.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: Yes; dual motor provides fully independent control of each breast’s suction and cycle settings.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 60
Max vacuum (mmHg): 248

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, true dual motor; settings independently adjustable per breast.
Rechargeable: Yes, rechargeable internal battery.
Size: Compact and highly portable; one of the smallest dual-motor pumps available.
Ease of Use: Generally straightforward controls; touchscreen intuitive but not overly sensitive.
Other: High build quality compared to competitors like Legendary Duette; affordable for dual-motor portability (under $150). Silicone 360 fit flanges, compatible with Idaho Jones and Pumpables Liquid flanges, making sizing customizable and comfortable. Ideal as a portable complement to a primary heavy-duty pump.

Sources:

Idaho Jones Moxi

Effect on Supply: Reliable for maintaining milk supply, suitable as a portable complement to heavier-duty pumps for most users.
Separate Vacuum/Cycle Speed Settings: No, three modes (stimulation, expression, and alternating) with fixed cycle/suction pairings. Cycle speeds top out around 70 cycles per minute.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 60
Max vacuum (mmHg): 248

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor; equal settings for both breasts.
Rechargeable: Yes, rechargeable internal battery.
Size: Compact and lightweight, slightly larger than Baby Buddha but similar to Pumpables Genie Advanced. Easy to carry with a small handle.
Ease of Use: Easy and intuitive; notably quiet during operation and portable for convenient use on the go.
Other: Affordably priced, includes comfortable silicone 360 fit flanges, making it a solid budget-friendly portable option.

Sources:

Ardo Alyssa

Effect on Supply: Effective for maintaining and moderately boosting supply, designed to be especially helpful for sensitive or delicate situations. Recommended for moms transitioning from hospital pumps, particularly those who used lower to mid-level suction on a Medela Symphony.
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: Yes; offers independent control with 8 vacuum levels and 8 cycle speed levels, providing over 120 customizable combinations—rare among portable pumps.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 50
Max vacuum (mmHg): 248

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor only; settings are the same for both breasts.
Rechargeable: Yes, rechargeable with an internal battery, but uses a proprietary charger rather than a standard USB, which can limit portability.
Size: Slightly larger than typical portable pumps (like Baby Buddha or Pumpables Genie Advanced). Portable enough to use comfortably in a fanny pack, but not ideal for pocket-carrying or neck-lanyard usage.
Ease of Use: Moderately easy to use; the touchscreen can be sensitive and occasionally finicky, but it also offers smartphone app control, allowing users easy, intuitive management of settings remotely.
Other: Unique features include a pre-programmed power-pumping mode, memory function for preferred settings, and excellent control over suction and cycle speed independently—rare for portable pumps. Minimal vibration makes it suitable for sensitive users. Compatible primarily with Ardo or Ameda parts for best performance; other brand parts may reduce effectiveness. Ideal for sensitive users needing gentle yet customizable pumping.

Sources:

Zommee Z2

Effect on Supply: Excellent for moms struggling with letdowns, due to unique alternating suction (left-right) and very high cycle speeds. Can empty breasts quickly, but moms must pump long enough for adequate stimulation to avoid potential supply dips.
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No, pre-programmed suction and cycle speeds.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 66
Max vacuum (mmHg): 280

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor with alternating (left-right) suction pattern.
Rechargeable: Yes, rechargeable battery.
Size: Medium-sized portable; larger than Baby Buddha but smaller than Spectra. Fits comfortably in fanny packs but slightly bulky when worn with provided lanyard.
Ease of Use: Touchscreen overly sensitive; prone to accidental adjustments, especially when moving around. Lack of touchscreen lock is a notable drawback.
Other: Unique alternating suction provides strong stimulation; can feel intense or fluttery—good for some moms, overwhelming for others. New updated Zomee Z2 has improved modes with more settings, better suction patterns, and stronger pulls. Offers complimentary flange sizing (15-28mm), making customization easy.

Sources:

5.1.2 Portable Pumps with Wearable Collection Cups

Elvie Stride 2

Effect on Supply: Improved over original Elvie Stride: Offers stronger suction and faster cycle speeds, shortening pumping sessions (now about 30 minutes vs. previous 35-40 minutes). Ideal for moms transitioning from pumps like Spectra; success rate higher (~70-80%).
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No, pre-programmed modes. Important to note that the simulation mode is very short (2-3 mins) which then automatically switches to expression mode.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 80
Max vacuum (mmHg): 255

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor operates both sides.
Rechargeable: Yes, rechargeable battery.
Size & Portability: Small and highly portable motor; easily fits in a fanny pack. Continues to be one of the quietest portable pumps on the market. Comes with a belt clip; however, durability issues have been noted.
Ease of Use: Smart pump, controlled via a convenient mobile app; minimal need to handle motor directly during pumping. Some issues with accidental setting changes if using belt clip; better secured with lanyard or fanny pack.
Cups and Inserts: Redesigned cups resemble Freemie cups; lower profile but increased limitations: Includes inserts (15, 17, 19, 21, 24, 28mm), but short tunnel length may limit effectiveness for larger nipples. Compatibility issues with third-party inserts; limited successful pairings (Pumping Pretty inserts recommended). Flat, harder surface of the collection cups may cause discomfort for some. Moms looking for a quiet, effective portable motor may benefit significantly from pairing the Stride 2 motor with alternative cups (e.g., Medela cups).

Source:

Medela Freestyle

Effect on Supply: Moderate to strong suction; relatively high cycle speeds. Effective for occasional or moderate use; not ideal for exclusive pumping due to motor durability.
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No. Pre-set modes (stimulation/expression), limited customization.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 78
Max vacuum (mmHg): 245

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): No, single motor.
Rechargeable: Yes, built-in rechargeable battery.
Size & Portability: Highly portable, compact, aesthetically pleasing. Ideal for on-the-go pumping.
Ease of Use & Noise: Improved motor; slightly quieter and less "quacking" sound than previous Freestyle Flex versions, though still noticeable noise. New model has better internal padding, reducing vibration significantly compared to earlier versions.
Cups and Inserts (Hands-Free Cups): New hands-free wearable cups available; compact, lightweight, and discreet with natural profile.

Easy assembly with only three parts; audible seal when properly assembled.
Limited flange sizes (currently 21 and 24mm); compatibility limited to certain inserts like Willow or Maymom short inserts.
5-ounce capacity, sufficient for many but limited for high-volume producers.
Concerns about durability due to thinner plastic and potential wear over time, especially at seals and tubing connectors.

Other: Replacement parts availability and pricing unclear. Tubing design may have durability concerns due to angled connector. Likely cross-compatible with other Medela flanges and setups, adding versatility.

Sources:

5.2 Wearable Pumps

Elvie OG

Effect on Supply: Traditional pull-and-release suction (not constant like Willow). Very gentle and comfortable, but typically takes longer (30–40 minutes) to fully empty breasts compared to other wearables or hospital-grade pumps.
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No. Offers two primary modes (stimulation and expression). With recent iOS updates ("Smart Rhythms"), it now includes helpful automated programs like Multi-Switch (cycles between stimulation/expression).

Max cycle speed in expression mode: no info
Max vacuum (mmHg): 220

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, dual motors with clearly labeled sides (left/right).
Rechargeable: Yes, fully rechargeable, portable wireless pump.
Size & Portability: Slim, discreet profile with a quiet motor; one of the quietest wearables available. Easy to wear under clothing without attracting attention. Sensitive design; parts can easily pop apart if not carefully handled.
Ease of Use & Noise: Quiet and discreet operation; excellent for subtle pumping. Assembly can be tricky due to silicone seals and tight fit. Slight learning curve involved. Excellent app control (start/stop, suction adjustments).

Advanced modes available only on iOS ("Multi-switch" and "Express and Collect"); not updated for Android, significantly limiting functionality on Android devices.

Other:

Flange & Bra Fit: Limited flange sizes (21, 24, 28mm), short tunnel may require inserts, especially for elastic nipples. Accurate bra fit is crucial for success.
Leaks & Design Flaws: Original design prone to leaks; recent iOS updates significantly reduced issue, but still not ideal for oversupply or heavy letdowns.
Maintenance & Costs: Frequent replacement of parts required (duckbills every 60–90 days, containers every 4–6 months). Handwashing recommended to maximize lifespan.

Sources:

Eufy S1 Pro

Effect on Supply: Traditional pull-and-release suction with a gentle, comfortable experience. Offers multiple suction modes (Max, Standard, Gentle, Natural), potentially suitable for most moms but not ideal if you require very strong or long pulls. The 'Natural' mode cycles closely mimic a baby's feeding pattern, likely maximizing milk output.
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: Moderate customization through four preset modes: Max, Standard, Gentle, and Natural. Each mode offers adjustable suction levels and three speeds. Includes auto-timed cycles which can simplify pumping sessions or power pumping. Natural mode seems to work well for most moms.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: no info
Max vacuum (mmHg): 300

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, dual motors with independent settings for each breast. Sync function available for easy simultaneous adjustments.
Rechargeable: Yes, fully rechargeable with a unique, compact charging case featuring magnetic docking technology—very convenient for on-the-go charging.
Size & Portability: Compact and discreet with a relatively slim design, though slightly thicker than some premium competitors. Innovative compact magnetic charging case enhances portability and ease of use.
Ease of Use & Noise: Assembly straightforward but involves careful alignment due to silicone seals and heating element connections. Moderate noise level—not as quiet as premium pumps (like Elvie), but acceptable for most everyday environments. Excellent app-based control (start/stop, suction adjustments, auto-modes).
Other Considerations:

Unique heating element (95–105°F) provides gentle warmth, potentially enhancing comfort and milk flow. Heating automatically disconnects if misaligned for safety.
Proprietary pump parts; potential future costs unknown but likely higher than generic replacements.
Limited initial insert sizes provided; may require third-party inserts for optimal fit, especially for elastic nipples.
Durability and warranty anticipated to be strong, given Eufy’s reputable history in electronics.

Sources:

Willow 3.0 & 360

Effect on Supply:

Uses constant suction rather than traditional pull-and-release, making it harder for some users to adjust.
Pump has slower cycle speeds (~42 cycles/min), which may require extra time for your body to learn to respond.
Usually takes 7–14 days postpartum to adjust; more challenging after 6 months postpartum.

Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No. Automatically switches from stimulation (2 mins) to expression mode, which can complicate letdown if your body isn't ready. Unable to return to stimulation mode after automatic switch, a significant limitation.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 42
Max vacuum (mmHg): 245

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, each cup has its own built-in motor.
Rechargeable: Yes, fully rechargeable wearable pump.
Size & Portability: Fully wearable, discreet, and completely cordless. Offers unmatched 360° mobility (truly leak-proof with bags). Heavy at about 1 pound per side, requiring precise bra fit to avoid discomfort or device damage. Usable discreetly, excellent for busy environments or hands-free activities.
Ease of Use & Noise: Quiet, suitable for workplace or public use. Significant learning curve due to unique constant-suction design, flip-to-finish method, and meticulous assembly. Requires thorough troubleshooting and precise fit; ongoing maintenance and part replacements needed (flex tubes: every 60–90 days; containers: every 3–6 months)
Other:

Flange Fit & Bra Support: Precise flange sizing (originally 24mm/27mm, inserts usually needed) and correct bra fit essential to avoid discomfort and device damage.
Milk Storage Options: Bags offer true leak-proof pumping; reusable containers less leak-resistant, difficult to clean thoroughly.
Output Limitations: Designed to auto-stop at ~4.5 oz; restarting mid-session difficult due to nipple swelling.
Durability & Quality (360 update): 360 corrects previous quality issues (3.0) but introduces no major innovations.
Cost & Maintenance: High ongoing costs for frequent replacement parts, containers, and bags.

Sources:

Willow Go

Effect on Supply:

Traditional pull-and-release suction (not constant suction as is the case for Willow 3.0 and 360); effective for most but may not fully empty breasts as well as hospital-grade pumps.

Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No, pre-programmed suction levels and cycle speeds. Auto-switches from stimulation (2–3 mins) to expression. Settings are adjustable manually or via app, but no advanced customization.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: no info
Max vacuum (mmHg): 280

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, dual independent motors, labeled clearly for left/right usage.
Rechargeable: Yes, fully rechargeable.
Size & Portability: Fully wearable, discreet, donut-shaped design fits comfortably into bra. Natural profile, lightweight, quiet, and easy to wear under clothing. Sensitive release buttons; must handle carefully to avoid damage.
Ease of Use & Noise: Quiet, discreet operation. Assembly has learning curve due to silicone parts; requires careful handling and cleaning.
Other:

Flange & Bra Fit: Available flanges: 21mm, 24mm, optional 27mm. Willow inserts (13mm–21mm) compatible. Precise flange and bra fit essential for effectiveness.
Maintenance & Cost: Parts (duckbill valves, diaphragms) require frequent replacement every 60–90 days; containers last ~3–6 months. Handwashing recommended for best longevity; dishwasher/sterilizer use decreases part lifespan significantly.
Recent Updates: Improved suction strength and cycle speed; new leak-guard container reduces spillage risk (not entirely leak-proof). App functionality enhanced with programmable suction and upcoming timer features.

Sources:

Zomee Fit

Effect on Supply: Offers strong suction and high cycle speeds (up to 102 cycles per minute), making it more efficient at emptying breasts compared to other budget wearables. Generally effective and comfortable, though not as powerful as premium pumps.
Separate Vacuum and Cycle Speed Settings: No. Limited customization, offering three preset modes: stimulation (short, fast cycles), expression (longer, stronger pulls), and a mixed mode alternating between both.

Max cycle speed in expression mode: 100
Max vacuum (mmHg): 260

Dual Motor (Independent Control for Each Breast): Yes, each breast has independent controls.
Rechargeable: Yes, fully rechargeable, portable wireless pump.
Size & Portability: Slimmer width but taller profile than some other pumps (like Elvie and Willow Go), meaning slightly less discreet under clothing. However, it remains wearable and practical for daily use.
Ease of Use: Straightforward, easy assembly and minimal learning curve compared to most wearables. Slightly louder than premium pumps (e.g., Elvie), with noticeable operational noise, but still acceptable in most environments.
Other Considerations:

Good compatibility with many inserts, suitable for elastic nipples.
Requires careful bra selection fit to avoid suction issues due to shape and size.
Duckbill valves are proprietary, occasionally experiencing supply shortages.
Parts lifespan average (duckbills every 60–90 days, diaphragms and containers 4–6 months).

Sources:

Momcozy

Momcozy pumps are extremely popular and widely marketed by influencers on social media, but we don't dive into individual models due to overall concerns with the brand. Despite being everywhere on social media—with videos of moms pumping and pouring unrealistic milk volumes—Momcozy pumps frequently have inconsistent performance, poor reliability, and some models have been reported to cause milk supply issues. Warranty coverage and customer service are reported to be inadequate, with claims often ignored, denied, or mishandled. Their aggressive marketing tactics, including offering high commissions to influencers, exploit the vulnerabilities of new moms seeking reliable solutions, creating misleading impressions of performance. For these reasons, we do not recommend or delve deeper into Momcozy breast pumps.

5.3 A Third Must-Have: The Medela Manual Pump

A manual pump might not be your everyday workhorse, but having one can be a lifesaver:

Power Outages: If your electric pump is out of juice and you can’t recharge, a manual pump ensures you aren’t left engorged.
Forgotten Parts: If you leave a valve or membrane at home, a manual pump covers you so you don’t skip a session at work.
Clogged Ducts: Manual expression (or a manual pump) can sometimes better target a specific area for relief.
Travel: It’s small, light, and needs no electricity—ideal for quick airport or car pumping.

Medela Harmony Manual Pump

Widely praised for its affordability, ease of use, and quiet operation.

Keep one at home and another at work (or in the car) for unexpected situations.

SECTION 6: Key Questions to Consider

Now that you know the main categories—Primary, Secondary, and Manual—and have a sense of typical suction/cycle speeds, here are the questions to ask yourself:

How Often Will I Pump?

Occasional pumping? A portable or manual might suffice.
Frequent or exclusive pumping? A primary pump is more reliable for sustaining supply.

Are You a First-Time Mom Unsure of Supply?

A robust primary pump (like a Spectra S1/S2 or Medela Symphony rental) is best. This way, you’re covered if your supply needs extra stimulation.

Insurance Coverage

Check what your insurance will provide. Many plans cover Spectra or Medela. You might pay to “upgrade” if your plan’s options are limited.

Hands-Free or Wearable Needs?

If you’ll be pumping at work, chasing older kids, or traveling a lot, a wearable or portable pump can be priceless.
Even a larger primary can be made discreet with Idaho Jones Pump-a-Collect cups and a Pump-a-Porter bag.

Lifestyle & Environment

If you have a consistent pumping station (say, a dedicated spot at home/office), a larger pump is fine. If you’re always on-the-go, consider adding a smaller pump to your collection or at least invest in a carrying solution.

Cost & Durability

Hospital-grade pumps can be expensive but might be rentable. Personal-use pumps vary widely in price. And remember to factor in the cost of the extra parts that will require regular replacement (valves, membranes, flanges).

Comfort & Flange Fit

A well fitting flange is absolutely crucial for your nipple and breast health, comfort and milk supply. Pain or rubbing can hinder letdown and is a threat to your long-term milk supply.

Future Family Plans

If you anticipate multiple kids, investing in a more durable or feature-rich pump can pay off in the long run.

These considerations help narrow down what kind of breast pump should I get and which breast pump is right for me based on your unique goals.

SECTION 7: Frequently Asked Questions

When Should I Order My Breast Pump?

Typically around the start of your third trimester, so you have time to set it up and learn how it works.

How Many Breast Pumps Do I Need?

One reliable primary pump is generally enough. Many parents keep a manual pump (like the Medela Harmony) for emergencies.

Which Pump is Best for Low Supply?

A hospital-grade model (e.g., Medela Symphony) or a robust personal-use pump (Spectra S1/S2, Unimom Opera, etc.) usually helps maintain or boost supply.

Can I Make a Big Pump Portable or Hands-Free?

Yes! Use collection cups (like Idaho Jones Pump-a-Collect) and pair your pump with a Pump-a-Porter or Pump-a-Porter Mini bag to move around freely.

Is a Manual Pump Enough for Daily Pumping?

It can be if you’re motivated, but most find it tiring. Manual pumps shine in backup situations—power outages, clogged ducts, or missed parts from your electric setup.

Do Stronger Suction Levels Produce More Milk?

Not necessarily. Comfort and letdown are key. Overly high suction can be painful, counterproductive and damage breast tissue.

Which Wearable Pump Should I Buy?

It depends on your budget and comfort preference. Elvie, Willow, and Zomee are popular, but if you need maximum output daily, consider pairing them with a strong primary pump.

What If My Flange Size Doesn’t Match the Pump’s Standard?

Many brands sell alternate flange sizes or adapters. Proper fit dramatically improves comfort and milk flow. You can always consider our revolutionary Cushy Silicone Flanges, soon available in 8 sizes.

SECTION 8: Conclusion

Picking a breast pump can seem daunting, but breaking it into categories helps. If you’re pumping frequently or suspect supply challenges, a primary pump (Spectra, Unimom, etc.) or a robust portable (BabyBuddha 2.0, Pumpables Genie Advanced) can give you the power and consistency you need. For hands-free convenience, wearable pumps offer unmatched mobility—though you might still want a strong primary at home. Meanwhile, a manual pump like the Medela Harmony is a must-have backup that can save you from awkward or painful situations.

Remember that accessories like collection cups (Idaho Jones Pump-a-Collect) and carrying solutions (Pump-a-Porter, Pump-a-Porter Mini) can transform even a bulky hospital-grade model into a more discreet and flexible setup. Assess your budget, schedule, baby’s needs, and personal comfort. Don’t hesitate to reach out to lactation consultants or check official manufacturer sites for more detailed specs. With the right pump(s) and accessories, you can create a pumping routine that fits into your life.

References

“Ameda Platinum Breast Pump.” Lactation Connection, https://lactationconnection.com/ameda-platinum-breast-pump-17803.

“ART-2151_Rev_A_Go_2.0_IFU_Instructions_For_Use_English_Artwork_Digital_Only.” Willow, https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1595/8015/files/ART-2151_Rev_A_Go_2.0_IFU_Instructions_For_Use_English_Artwork_Digital_Only.pdf?v=1733499269.

“Baby Buddha Pump Review.” Mommy Labor Nurse, https://blog.mommylabornurse.com/baby-buddha-pump-review.

“Best Hospital Grade Pumps for Pumping Moms.” Living with Low Milk Supply, https://livingwithlowmilksupply.com/best-hospital-grade-breast-pumps-for-pumping-moms.

“Breast Pump.” Cleveland Clinic, https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/25244-breast-pump. Accessed 6 Mar. 2025.

“Breast Pump Buying Guide.” Consumer Reports, https://www.consumerreports.org/babies-kids/breast-pumps/buying-guide/. Accessed 6 Mar. 2025.

“Breastpumps.” Genuine Lactation, https://www.genuinelactation.com/breastpumps.

“Choosing Your Breast Pump: A Complete Guide by Natasha Dodge.” Breastfeeding Center, 28 May 2021, https://www.breastfeedingcenter.org/blog/2021/5/28/choosing-your-breast-pump-a-complete-guide-by-natasha-dodge.

“Elvie Pump Manual.” Elvie, https://cdn2.elvie.com/elvie-website/assets/manuals/aw-000562-e-combined_multi-language_elvie_pump_manual_final.pdf.

“Freestyle Hands-Free Instruction Manual.” Medela, https://www.medela.com/010-products/010-pumps/010-hands-free-electric/010-freestyle-hands-free/pdf-downloads/101044530-2022-04-a-freestyle-hands-free-md-ifu-en-es-fr-3-.pdf.

“Genie Advanced Portable Breast Pump Review.” New Little Life, 25 May 2022, https://www.newlittlelife.com/2022/05/25/genie-advanced-portable-breast-pump-review/.

“How to Buy a Breast Pump.” Wired, https://www.wired.com/story/how-to-buy-a-breast-pump/. Accessed 6 Mar. 2025.

“How to Choose a Breast Pump.” Medela, https://www.medela.com/en/breastfeeding-pumping/articles/pumping-tips/how-to-choose-a-breast-pump. Accessed 6 Mar. 2025.

“Idaho Jones Breast Pumps.” Exclusive Pumping, https://exclusivepumping.com/idaho-jones-breast-pump.

“Picking Your Pump: Top 5 Questions.” Aeroflow Breastpumps, https://aeroflowbreastpumps.com/blog/picking-your-pump-top-5-questions.

“Primary Pumps.” Genuine Lactation Blog for Breastfeeding Families, https://www.genuinelactation.com/blog-for-breastfeeding-families/primarypumps.

“Spectra S1 Breast Pump | A Detailed Review.” Living with Low Milk Supply, https://livingwithlowmilksupply.com/spectra-breast-pump-reviews.

“Spectra Synergy Gold Manual.” Spectra Baby USA, https://www.spectrababyusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/SG-Synergy-Gold-Manual.pdf.

“Spectra Synergy Gold Review.” Be My Breast Friend, https://bemybreastfriend.com/blogs/primary-breast-pump-reviews/spectra-synergy-gold-review.

“Unimom Opera Breast Pump Review.” Exclusive Pumping, https://exclusivepumping.com/unimom-opera/.

“Updated Elvie Review.” New Little Life, 24 Jan. 2025, https://www.newlittlelife.com/2025/01/24/updated-elvie-review/.

“Which Spectra Pump Is Right for Me?” Spectra Baby USA, https://www.spectrababyusa.com/which-spectra-pump-is-right-for-me-2/.

“Zomee Fit Review.” New Little Life, 22 Jan. 2025, https://www.newlittlelife.com/2025/01/22/zomee-fit-review/.

“Zomee Z2 Review.” Genuine Lactation, https://www.genuinelactation.com/blog-for-breastfeeding-families/zomeez2updated.

YouTube. “BabyBuddha Pump Overview | Should You Get It?” Uploaded by Genuine Lactation, 17 Nov. 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1njddzBDIyE.

YouTube. “Elvie Review & Set Up.” Uploaded by New Little Life, 24 Jan. 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izqs63JYUIo.

YouTube. “Eufy S1 Pro | Full Review + Demo.” Uploaded by Be My Breast Friend, 18 Jan. 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zK_NQs9RPxQ.

YouTube. “How to Use the Medela Freestyle Pump.” Uploaded by Genuine Lactation, 19 Mar. 2024, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2BWQUxV6bU.

YouTube. “Idaho Jones Breast Pump Review.” Uploaded by Exclusive Pumping, 28 Feb. 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTiJet11TYU.

YouTube. “Pumpables Genie Advanced Review.” Uploaded by New Little Life, 25 May 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4BB_pQ5je0&t=118s.

YouTube. “Spectra S1 vs S2 vs Synergy Gold.” Uploaded by Genuine Lactation, 10 Oct. 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muaOP1h5VQE.

YouTube. “Unimom Opera Pump Review.” Uploaded by Exclusive Pumping, 5 May 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiXYNwj1eFU.

YouTube. “Willow Go Review.” Uploaded by Be My Breast Friend, 5 Jan. 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFo1SxEjRYE.

YouTube. “Zomee Fit Review.” Uploaded by New Little Life, 22 Jan. 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nDNRkQQPESc.

Back to blog

Your cart is empty

Best Sellers

Best Sellers

Your cart

Estimated total

How to Pick a Breast Pump

Subscribe to our emails